Current:Home > FinanceMichigan’s top court throws out 2006 conviction linked to shaken baby syndrome-InfoLens
Michigan’s top court throws out 2006 conviction linked to shaken baby syndrome
View Date:2024-12-23 18:32:59
DETROIT (AP) — The Michigan Supreme Court overturned a 2006 murder conviction in the death of an infant in an appeal that centered on new opinions about so-called shaken baby syndrome.
The court said Chazlee Lemons, who is serving a life prison sentence, deserves a new trial. Her lawyers have lined up scientific experts, and the doctor who performed the autopsy nearly 20 years ago changed his opinion on the manner of Nakita Lemons’ death.
It’s probable that a “jury would have a reasonable doubt” about Lemons’ guilt, the court said Thursday in a 5-2 decision led by Justice Megan Cavanagh.
Lemons was represented by the Innocence Clinic at University of Michigan Law School, which has successfully challenged similar convictions across the state.
An email seeking comment from the Wayne County prosecutor’s office wasn’t immediately answered Friday.
Nakita, who had experienced breathing problems since birth, was a few months old when she died while in Lemons’ care in 2005. The prosecutor charged the parent with first-degree murder, based on autopsy results and her statements to police.
Lemons told police that she shook Nakita three or four times to get her to stop crying, according to a summary of the case.
Dr. Bader Cassin, who performed the autopsy, said his examination revealed a swollen brain and retinal hemorrhages. At trial, he classified the death as shaken baby syndrome. Lemons’ lawyer at that time did not offer an expert to rebut Cassin.
But Cassin’s opinion changed in 2017 during an effort to reopen the case in Wayne County court. He said Nakita could have choked on baby formula. He noted that biomechanical scientists had demonstrated that the forces in shaking were insufficient to produce the injury.
The Innocence Clinic also offered experts, including a biomechanical engineer with experience researching head injuries. Prosecutors had their own experts to back up the shaken baby syndrome theory. A judge and the state appeals court ultimately upheld Lemons’ conviction.
The Supreme Court acknowledged that Lemons had made incriminating statements to police about shaking Nakita. But the court said a jury at a new trial might find that the confession was false.
“As we have recognized elsewhere, suspects presented with seemingly incontrovertible physical evidence of their guilt may confess falsely to ameliorate their current conditions,” the court said.
In dissent, Justice Brian Zahra accused the majority of relying on “extraordinarily suspect evidence” to rule in favor of Lemons and reverse the decisions of a prominent Detroit-area judge. Zahra said there wasn’t scientific evidence to believe the brain injuries were caused by choking on formula.
In a court filing, the American Academy of Pediatrics supported the prosecutor and had urged the Supreme Court not to be swayed by “fringe courtroom science” questioning head injuries.
___
Follow Ed White on X at https://twitter.com/edwritez
veryGood! (97)
Related
- Who will be in the top 12? Our College Football Playoff ranking projection
- 'Heart of Stone' review: Gal Gadot shoots but Netflix superspy thriller doesn't score
- Fashion Nova shoppers to get refunds after settlement: How to file a claim
- Connecticut school district lost more than $6 million in cyber attack, so far gotten about half back
- Jelly Roll goes to jail (for the best reason) ahead of Indianapolis concert
- US probing Virginia fatal crash involving Tesla suspected of running on automated driving system
- Alabama panel approves companies to grow, distribute medical marijuana
- NYC teen dies in apparent drowning after leaping off ledge of upstate waterfall
- What does the top five look like and other questions facing the College Football Playoff committee
- Coach parent Tapestry and Versace owner Capri fashion a $8.5 billion merger
Ranking
- Texas now tops in SEC? Miami in trouble? Five overreactions to college football Week 11
- Worldcoin scans eyeballs and offers crypto. What to know about the project from OpenAI’s CEO
- Kyle Richards’ Husband Mauricio Umansky Reacts to Her Steamy New Morgan Wade Video
- NOAA doubles the chances for a nasty Atlantic hurricane season due to hot ocean, tardy El Nino
- Sister Wives’ Christine Brown Shares Glimpse Into Honeymoon One Year After Marrying David Woolley
- Jury awards family of New York man who died after being beaten by police $35 million in damages
- To the moon and back: Astronauts get 1st look at Artemis II craft ahead of lunar mission
- 'Henry Hamlet’s Heart' and more LGBTQ books to read if you loved 'Heartstopper'
Recommendation
-
College Football Playoff bracket: Complete playoff picture after latest rankings
-
Bethany Joy Lenz Says One Tree Hill Costars Tried to Rescue Her From Cult
-
Kelly Clarkson Switches Lyrics to “Piece By Piece” After Brandon Blackstock Divorce
-
Killing of Ecuador candidate deepens country’s sense of vulnerability to crime
-
Megan Fox Is Pregnant, Expecting Baby With Machine Gun Kelly
-
Why some people believe ginger ale is good for you. (And why it's actually not.)
-
Two men, woman die trying to rescue dog from cistern in Texas corn field
-
Halle Berry Is Challenging Everything About Menopause and Wants You to Do the Same